Choosing the right carpet installation company is vital for a successful flooring project. The Carpet Guys and Empire Today are two of America’s top choices, each offering unique benefits and services. This in-depth comparison examines the key differences and similarities between The Carpet Guys and Empire, highlighting what homeowners should know before making a decision.
Carpet Guys Vs Empire At A Glance
| Feature | The Carpet Guys | Empire Today (Empire) |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage Area | Midwest (mainly Michigan, expanding to parts of Ohio & Indiana) | Nationwide (48 states) |
| Product Range | Carpet, hardwood, laminate, vinyl plank, tile | Carpet, hardwood, laminate, luxury vinyl, tile |
| In-Home Estimates | Free, scheduled consultations | Free, same-day possible |
| Installation Speed | Next-day (in some areas), standard 2-5 days | Next-day available |
| Warranty | Lifetime installation guarantee | Limited lifetime installation warranty |
| Customer Service Reputation | Highly rated locally, strong community ties | Mixed reviews, national scale |
Company Backgrounds And Histories
The Carpet Guys
The Carpet Guys were founded in 2010 and are headquartered in Troy, Michigan. They’ve grown rapidly throughout the Midwest, earning a reputation for local service, hands-on ownership, and strong community involvement. Their business model focuses on personalized in-home consultations, tailored flooring selections, and fast turnaround.
Empire Today (Empire)
Empire Today Inc. (commonly known as Empire) was founded in 1959 and is a national flooring retailer headquartered outside of Chicago, Illinois. Empire has become famous for its catchy “800-588-2300…Empire Today!” jingle and aggressive advertising. Their huge network covers almost all of the continental US, offering standardized service and an efficient, rapid response model.
Service Areas And Availability
The Carpet Guys Service Coverage
The Carpet Guys primarily serve the Metro Detroit area, much of Michigan, and are expanding into Ohio and Indiana. Their business is regional, letting them build a strong reputation with local customers and maintain high-quality control. Clients outside the Midwest will need to look elsewhere for similar services.
Empire Today Service Coverage
Empire Today has one of the largest direct-service footprints in the flooring industry, serving 48 states across America. If you live in an area not covered by The Carpet Guys, Empire is a readily available alternative. Their national model enables next-day installation for most major metropolitan areas.
Flooring Products Offered
Both companies offer a wide selection of flooring materials, but there are subtle differences in availability and specialization.
The Carpet Guys Products
- Carpet: Wide selection, including stain-resistant and pet-friendly options
- Hardwood: Solid and engineered hardwood flooring
- Laminate Flooring: Multiple styles and durability levels
- Luxury Vinyl Plank: Offers waterproof, flexible, and rigid-core planks
- Tile: Porcelain, ceramic, and specialty options
Empire Today Products
- Carpet: Large variety, focus on budget and durability
- Hardwood Flooring: Wide assortment, traditional and new styles
- Laminate Flooring: Wide range, including water-resistant
- Luxury Vinyl Tile (LVT) & Plank (LVP): Significant inventory
- Tile: Ceramic, porcelain, and more
Both offer popular brands and house-label lines to fit a range of budgets and design tastes.
In-Home Shopping Experience And Estimates
The core value proposition of both companies is their free, in-home shopping service. This mobile business model eliminates the need for customers to visit a showroom, instead bringing floor samples and an expert directly to the home.
- The Carpet Guys schedules a design consultant who brings curated flooring samples selected for your needs. The expert measures rooms and provides a written estimate on the spot. Customers appreciate their focus on needs assessment and education.
- Empire Today representatives can often schedule same-day appointments. Their process includes measuring, consulting, and offering immediate quotes. Empire’s speedy response appeals to those seeking the fastest turnaround.
Both companies offer transparent, line-item pricing and no-pressure sales approaches on most visits. However, customer reviews occasionally report upsell attempts or price variations, so due diligence is advised.
Installation Services Compared
Scheduling And Speed
Empire Today’s signature promise is “next-day installation,” offered for most in-stock products in eligible areas. Their large network makes this a reality for many customers looking for immediate results.
The Carpet Guys match this agility in many markets, offering next-day or rapid scheduling where possible. Their smaller operation sometimes means slightly longer waits during peak demand but allows for greater attention to detail.
Installers And Quality Assurance
- The Carpet Guys use thoroughly vetted, in-house installation crews or tightly controlled contractors. They emphasize craftsmanship, attention to trim and transition work, and handle both complex and standard jobs.
- Empire Today relies on a vast network of contracted installers. The scale allows for blanket coverage, but quality may depend on the particular team assigned. Clients are urged to confirm experience and installation standards during the estimate.
Preparation And Cleanup
Both companies offer furniture moving (within reason) and removal/disposal of old flooring. Carpet stretching, subfloor repair, and trim options can be included in the estimate. Post-installation cleanup is standard.
Warranty And After-Sales Support
The Carpet Guys Warranty
The Carpet Guys stand out with a “Lifetime Installation Guarantee”, which covers workmanship for as long as the client owns the home. Product warranties from the manufacturer are also honored, ranging from 5 years to lifetime, depending on the floor selected.
Empire Today Warranty
Empire offers a “Limited Lifetime Installation Warranty,” covering defects in installation for the life of the product. Manufacturer warranties vary by brand and type, so customers should review documentation carefully.
Both companies offer dedicated after-sales support and will dispatch crews for repair or adjustment under warranty terms. The local focus of The Carpet Guys can result in faster warranty response times and more personalized service.
Customer Service And Reputation
The Carpet Guys Reviews
- Extremely strong local reviews – averaging 4.7 stars on Google and A+ BBB ratings
- Praise for professionalism, clear communication, efficient installation, and consistent follow-through
- Noted for their personal touch, local ownership, and charity/community initiatives
- Occasional complaints about scheduling in busy seasons or minor post-installation adjustments
Empire Today Reviews
- Mixed customer feedback – reviews range widely depending on location and installer
- Praise for availability, wide product selection, and speedy installation process
- Criticisms often cite inconsistent installation quality and pushy sales tactics on some appointments
- B- BBB rating and similar star averages on many review platforms
Empire’s size means your experience may depend on the specific local partner or crew assigned.
Pricing Models And Promotions
Both The Carpet Guys and Empire avoid quoting fixed prices online, since flooring costs depend on material, area covered, subfloor condition, and extras like stairs or custom trim. Customers receive written proposals after in-home measurements.
- The Carpet Guys focus on “all-inclusive” upfront pricing, often including install, pad, moving most furniture, trim, and haul away.
- Empire is known for regular, heavily advertised sales like “$50 off each room” or “Buy 1 Room, Get 2 Free,” though actual savings vary depending on details.
Both offer financing options through third-party providers, enabling customers to spread payments over 12-48 months, often with promotional interest rates for qualified buyers. Always verify and compare the bottom-line, out-the-door price.
Eco-Friendly And Specialized Options
The demand for sustainable flooring and indoor air-quality friendly products has grown significantly. Both companies are responding with options for eco-conscious homeowners:
- The Carpet Guys promote “green” carpet lines featuring low-VOC adhesives and backing, plus hardwood from certified sources.
- Empire Today offers carpet with GreenGuard Certification and formaldehyde-free flooring options, as well as hypoallergenic solutions.
If environmental considerations or health concerns are priorities, request details during your in-home consultation.
Unique Selling Points For Each Company
Why Choose The Carpet Guys?
- Locally owned and operated with a focus on personalized service and community reputation
- Proven track record in the Midwest
- Lifetime installation guarantee and strong post-sale follow-up
- Direct contact with management and real people supporting your job
Why Choose Empire Today?
- Nationwide reach and nearly instant appointment/installation turnaround
- Massive selection of products and styles
- Well-known brand, regular national promotions
- Ideal for those needing next-day service almost anywhere
Comparing The Process: Step-By-Step
| Step | The Carpet Guys | Empire Today |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Contact | Request via phone or website. Local team follows up to schedule consult. | Online or phone booking, often same-day appointment available. |
| In-Home Consultation | Design expert brings tailored samples, assesses needs, measures, and provides quote. | Representative brings wide range of samples, advises on options, measures, and quotes. |
| Estimate & Pricing | Detailed, itemized, usually includes all necessary services. | Line-item quote; price valid for period; promotional offers may apply. |
| Installation Scheduling | Next-day or as soon as possible, depending on stock/crew availability. | Next-day usually available, particularly in metro areas. |
| After-Sales Support | Responsive to follow-up, warranty claims handled by local office. | National call center; local teams handle warranty/service requests. |
Comparison Of Strengths And Weaknesses
| Factor | The Carpet Guys | Empire Today |
|---|---|---|
| Local Reputation | Excellent (particularly in Michigan) | Varies greatly by location |
| Speed | Fast, but can depend on crew availability in peak times | Very fast (next-day in most cases) |
| Personalization | Strong, consultative sales and design support | Good/average, but less personal due to scale |
| Pricing Transparency | All-inclusive quoting, limited upsells | National promos, but actual discounts can vary |
| Warranty Quality | Lifetime installation coverage | Limited lifetime installation warranty |
How To Decide: Factors To Consider
For those weighing Carpet Guys vs Empire, consider these factors:
- Your location: The Carpet Guys offer top service if you’re inside their Midwest zone; Empire wins on nationwide access.
- Turnaround speed: Both can deliver next-day, but Empire has a larger installer pool for near-instant timeline.
- Service style: Prefer local, hands-on, and community-driven? Choose The Carpet Guys. Value brand recognition and massive inventory? Empire is a fit.
- Pricing: Verify “out the door” costs from both. Watch for hidden fees in national promos.
- Aftercare: If long-term relationship and warranty support are key, local providers often perform better.
Frequently Asked Questions About Carpet Guys Vs Empire
Are The Carpet Guys And Empire Both Licensed, Bonded, And Insured?
Yes, both companies maintain proper business licensing and insurance for their operations and teams in each operating state.
Who Offers The Lowest Prices?
Actual job costs are influenced by flooring type, area size, and project complexity. Empire aggressively markets discounts nationally, but sometimes The Carpet Guys’ local focus can produce superior bundled deals. Always request written, itemized quotes.
How Are Review Scores Different?
The Carpet Guys maintain a notably higher cumulative review score in Michigan and nearby regions. Empire’s score is more variable, with some locations excelling and others lagging depending on installer quality.
Does Either Company Handle Commercial Flooring?
Empire serves select commercial accounts (offices, apartment buildings). The Carpet Guys are primarily residential but may accept small business projects by request.
Is It Possible To Get A Same-Day Estimate Or Service?
Empire offers same-day appointments often, especially in cities. The Carpet Guys prioritize next-day or soonest possible service, although same-day may happen during slow periods.
Can I Supply My Own Flooring Or Do I Need To Buy Through The Company?
Both companies generally require the product to be purchased from them to guarantee installation and warranty. For exceptions, discuss your situation directly during the consultation.
Final Tips For Choosing Between Carpet Guys Vs Empire
- Read independent, local reviews for your specific area—they can reveal much about installer quality and aftercare.
- Be wary of high-pressure tactics. Both companies emphasize “no pressure,” but some reps may push same-day signings for discounts. Take time to compare quotes.
- Review the warranty’s exact terms, especially exclusions for stairs, pet damage, or subfloor issues.
- Ask about special promotions, financing deals, and what is (or isn’t) included in the base price.
- If sustainability or hypoallergenic flooring is a priority, request documentation and certifications before purchase.
Choosing between The Carpet Guys and Empire comes down to your priorities: local touch and reputation, or nationwide reach and rapid response. Either can deliver a quality result when properly researched and selected for your needs.